Poor old #97 lived a full life......... She was ridden hard and put away wet, literally. Hmm, the challenges of working with old used parts. Judging by the looks of that alt.cover, there are marks in it no amount of polishing will eliminate........ ?? But the cover will look ALOT better after you are finished with it than it does now. The good part about "it" is, when the restoration is complete, the small blemishes left in the cover will be overshadowed ("drowned out") by the magnificence of the completed machine. It's always hard, with our critical eye, when we focus on one part and know every last blemish of each and every part, these things always stand out and look worse than when the machine is assembled and these small things fade into the completed project. As Chris says, there's always some compromise involved with decisions we make. Myself, i would dress down as best possible the external crack, perhaps explore some aluminum filler to help hide the outer crack. The good part, the crack is on the under side. The inside, i would rough up with a Dremel, then JB Weld.